Caught more fish than any other trip I’ve been on, and I’ve been on a lot.  Noah really knows how to get you on top of the fish and teaches you how to catch them.  Great Captain!

Boat and gear was great. Captain Noah was very knowledgeable. Got us over a wreck and they were biting. Had over 30 hook up, only got 6 to the boat though between the sharks and barracuda. Caught a couple jacks and snappers enough for good lunch overall a really great morning. Thanks so much would definitely go again.

We had a great first time deep sea fishing with Captain Sam! He took the time to teach us how to properly reel and made sure each person on board caught a fish. We could tell he worked hard to guarantee we had a great time. The only improvement we could give would be to have an assistant for him so one could be driving the boat while the other assisted with the lines/rods. Overall we highly recommend and plan to use Fish Key West for our next charter adventure!

I’ve been on several fishing chargers before and Sam was the best captain I’ve ever had. Sam was very knowledgeable and organized on this fishing charter. We caught over 20 fish and he filleted the mutton snapper up for my wife and I and suggested we take it to hurricane hole, a restaurant about 10 Mins away for them to make fish tacos. They were delicious, highly recommended booking a trip with Sam as he was very friendly and easy going and was a blast to be around!

Absolutely recommend Joey and Coolcast Charter! My husband and I did a fishing trip last time we were in Key West but this blew it out of the water! Great captain and a very hands on trip, actually being able to bait your own hook on your own pole - He knew when and where to move the boat when we weren’t catching anything right away, very friendly and informative. 11/10 recommend and will definitely be coming back on our next trip! Thanks for the best experience!